Skip to content
Call

Insights · Risk profile

Your EMR is a sales number

The experience modification rate was designed to price workers' compensation. General contractors use it to decide who gets invited. What it is, how it moves, why GCs read it before your bid, and how to talk about yours.

November 12, 2026 · 7 min read

a man standing on top of a metal structure
Photo: Ivan Henao / Unsplash

Most subcontractors learn about their experience modification rate from an insurance renewal. They learn what it costs them from a GC that never called.

What the number is

The experience modification rate, usually called the EMR or the mod, is a factor applied to your workers’ compensation premium. It compares your company’s actual claims over a three-year window to what a company of your size in your trade would be expected to have. A mod of 1.0 means you had the expected claims. A mod of 0.80 means you had fewer, and your premium is 20 percent lower. A mod of 1.25 means more, and 25 percent higher.

The window is the three policy years ending one year before the current one, so a claim takes a year to show up and three years to roll off. The formula weights the number of claims more heavily than their size, because frequency predicts future injuries better than severity does. Five small claims hurt the mod more than one large one.

That is what it was designed for. It is not what GCs use it for.

Why a GC reads it before your bid

A general contractor’s prequalification form has a line for the EMR, and most GCs apply a cutoff to it. A mod of 1.0 or below passes everywhere. Between 1.0 and 1.2, some GCs ask questions and some pass you through. Above 1.2, many will not consider a sub at all, and above about 1.25 almost none will. Public owners and large private owners often write the cutoff into the bid documents, so the GC has no discretion even if it wanted some.

There are three reasons, and they are all about the GC’s money, not yours.

First, the mod is the only standardized, third-party number on the form. Everything else a sub reports about safety is self-reported. The mod comes from a rating bureau, from actual claims, and it cannot be dressed up.

Second, on a wrap-up policy, where the GC or the owner buys the workers’ compensation for every trade on the job, a sub’s mod feeds the cost of the program. A sub at 1.3 raises the GC’s own insurance cost.

Third, a high mod predicts injuries, and an injury on a commercial job stops work, brings OSHA, and shows up in the GC’s own record. A GC with its own mod to protect does not hire subs that will raise it.

So the estimator reads the mod before the number. A sub above the cutoff is filtered out before anyone sees the bid, and the sub never finds out that it was the mod and not the price.

How much it is costing you

A sub with a 1.3 mod and a $3M revenue goal has two problems. The premium is roughly 30 percent above a 1.0 shop’s, which on a $100,000 workers’ comp premium is $30,000 a year. That is the problem the insurance agent talks about.

The other problem is every GC with a 1.2 cutoff, which is most of the ones with larger work, and every public job with the cutoff in the documents. The sub is not losing those bids. It is not being invited to them, and the dollar figure on that is whatever those jobs would have been worth. For most subs the second number is a multiple of the first.

How it moves

Because the window is three years and the formula weights frequency, the mod moves slowly, and it moves on small claims.

  • A single bad year with several recordable injuries pushes the mod up for three years.
  • Closing claims matters: an open claim is valued at the reserve the carrier set, which is usually higher than what it settles for. Reviewing open claims with your agent before the rating date, and pushing to close the ones that should be closed, lowers the mod on paper before any safety change takes effect.
  • Reporting matters: a medical-only claim, where the injured worker loses no time, is counted at a fraction of its cost in most states. Getting an injured worker back to light duty quickly keeps a claim medical-only.
  • Payroll matters: the expected losses side of the formula is based on your payroll by class code. Misclassified payroll, with office staff coded as field, raises the expected losses and can lower the mod when corrected; the reverse is also true, and an audit will find it.

A sub that starts a real safety program, with a named person, toolbox talks, a return-to-work policy and claims reviews, usually sees the mod turn in the second year and reach the new level by the third. The GC checks the trend as well as the number, which is why the trend belongs on your capabilities page.

How to talk about yours

The prequalification form has a box for the number and no box for the story. Where the mod is above 1.0, the story has to travel with the number, and the sub has to carry it.

Put the three-year trend on the capabilities page, as three numbers, not one. “EMR: 1.18, 1.09, 0.96” tells an estimator everything a paragraph would, and tells it before the form is sent. If one year has a reason, say it in a sentence: one claim, closed, program changed since. Have the person who returns the prequalification form ready to say the same thing on the phone, because the estimator who is on the fence will call.

Do not argue with the number. A sub that explains why the mod is unfair sounds like a sub that will explain why the schedule was unfair. A sub that says what happened and what changed sounds like a sub that manages things.

What to do, in order

  1. Get the mod worksheet from your agent, not just the number. It lists every claim in the window and the payroll by class. Check both.
  2. Review every open claim with the agent before the next rating date. Push to close what should be closed.
  3. Put a return-to-work policy in writing so the next injury stays medical-only where it can.
  4. Name someone to run safety and give them the hour a week it takes. Your carrier’s loss-control people will help for free.
  5. Put the three-year trend on the capabilities page and in the packet, with the one-sentence story where a year needs one.

An EMR above 1.25 is one of the six blockers in the Bid-Ready Score: a sub there starts in Foundation whatever else is true, because GCs filter on it before anything else. The good news is that it is the most fixable number on the form, and the fix starts with a worksheet your agent already has.


Find out where you stand. It takes fifteen minutes.

One call with a Partner, and thirty-six questions you answer in your own time first. You leave with your Bid-Ready Score, the package that fits the size you want next, and the first three things to fix, whether or not you ever hire us.

No obligation. No pitch deck. If you are not ready for any of the packages yet, you will hear that too.